Perfectionism In parenting or Perfectionist parenting, characterized by unrealistic expectations and a focus on achievements over personal growth, can have detrimental effects on both parents and their children. Research has shown that striving for perfection in parenting often leads to burnout among parents and mental health issues in their children.
Research Findings
A comprehensive study conducted by researchers from The Ohio State University College of Nursing and the university’s Office of the Chief Wellness Officer has shed light on the detrimental effects of the societal pressure to be a “perfect parent” on both parents and their children. The study, which surveyed over 700 parents nationwide, and summarized in the report “The Power of Positive Parenting: Evidence to Help Parents and Their Children Thrive,” reveals significant findings regarding parental burnout and its impact on children’s mental health.
The research highlights that parental burnout is closely linked to internal and external expectations. These expectations encompass feelings of inadequacy as a parent, perceived judgment from others, insufficient time for play with children, strained relationships with spouses, and the burden of maintaining a clean household. The study found that 57% of parents reported experiencing burnout, indicating a widespread issue within the parenting community.
The study underscores the importance of free playtime and a lighter load of structured extracurricular activities for children. It suggests that these factors significantly reduce the likelihood of mental health issues in children, such as anxiety, depression, OCD, ADHD, and bipolar disorder. This finding emphasizes the critical role of parents’ mental health and behaviors in shaping their children’s mental health outcomes.
Interestingly, the study also revealed a correlation between parental burnout and harsh parenting practices. Parents who reported higher levels of burnout were more likely to engage in behaviors such as insulting, criticizing, screaming at, cursing at, and/or physically harming their children. This association between parental burnout and harsh parenting practices further underscores the cyclical nature of the problem, as higher levels of self-reported parental burnout and harsh parenting practices are associated with more mental health problems in children.
The research further provides insights into the psychological impact of parental pressure on children. It highlights that children facing frequent verbal criticism and unrealistic expectations from parents are at a higher risk for depression and negative self-talk. They may internalize this criticism, leading to harsh self-talk and a diminished sense of self-worth. Additionally, children whose parents exert pressure through teasing about weight or policing their eating habits are more likely to develop eating disorders and poor body image. Even well-intentioned comments about appearance can send the message that they’re being judged, contributing to their psychological distress.
Keep in mind that while parents often push their children academically with the hope of motivating them, children with controlling parents tend to perform worse in school. This constant pressure can sap their intrinsic motivation, leading to academic underperformance. Moreover, when affection and approval are conditional on meeting parental expectations, children often start to withdraw socially. They may hide their true feelings, avoid asking for help, and struggle to form close relationships.
The study concludes by emphasizing the importance of positive parenting strategies, which involve giving children a lot of love and warmth while also providing structure and guidance. This approach encourages parents to gently teach their children the consequences of their behaviors, aiming for a balance between love and discipline. The researchers suggest that focusing on positive parenting can help alleviate the burden of parental burnout and foster healthier relationships between parents and their children.
Strategies to Combat Perfectionist Parenting
To combat perfectionist parenting and help children overcome unhealthy perfectionism, several strategies can be implemented:
Encourage High Standards, Not Perfection: Emphasize the importance of striving for excellence rather than perfection. Psychologist Randy Frost advises against pursuing perfection but highlights the benefits of setting high standards. Miriam Adderholdt distinguishes between excellence and perfectionism, emphasizing the demoralizing nature of perfectionism.
Teach Your Child “The Power of Yet”: Introduce the concept of “the power of yet” to help children understand that success requires time, effort, and learning from mistakes. By focusing on progress and improvement rather than achieving perfection, children can develop a growth mindset and resilience. This approach involves creating drafts, acknowledging achievements, providing constructive feedback, and allowing for downtime.
Redefine Success: Foster a growth mindset in children by teaching them that success is a result of effort and strategies, not fixed traits like intelligence. Encourage children to view mistakes as opportunities for learning and growth. Reading books and watching shows that depict characters overcoming failures can help reinforce this mindset.
Challenge Perfectionistic Thinking: Help children challenge their unforgiving and distorted thoughts by staying calm, practicing empathy, and guiding them to reframe negative thinking patterns. Encourage children to reflect on the worst-case scenario, positive perspectives, and actionable solutions when faced with perfectionistic thoughts.
Explain the Brain Muscle: Educate children about the brain’s ability to grow and develop through facing challenges. Emphasize that mistakes and struggles are essential for learning and brain development. Encourage children to see setbacks as opportunities for growth and brain strengthening.
Talk About Your Mistakes: Model self-compassion and resilience by sharing your own mistakes and failures with your child. By normalizing mistakes and demonstrating how they can lead to growth and learning, children can develop a healthier perspective on imperfection and self-acceptance.
By implementing these strategies, parents can create a supportive environment that promotes healthy standards, resilience, and a growth mindset, ultimately helping children combat perfectionism and develop a positive self-image.
ALSO READ: 10 Amazing Benefits Of Tummy Time For Babies That Every Parent Should Know
Resources
- https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/05/240508093726.htm
- https://nursing.osu.edu/sites/default/files/2024-05/OCWO_ParentalBurnout_3674200_Report_2024Update_FINAL_2.pdf
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6230657/
